FIA president Mohammed Ben Sulayem has provided clarity on the departure of former Formula 1 driver Johnny Herbert from his role as a race steward.
Herbert, who has served in this capacity alongside other ex-drivers for the last 15 years, will no longer officiate due to a recognized conflict of interest stemming from his media commitments.
The FIA decided that Herbert’s public commentary in the media was “incompatible” with the impartiality required of a steward, leading to his stepping down before the start of the 2025 season.
This move has sparked discussions on the nature of stewarding within Formula 1, highlighting areas where the sport might evolve.
Steward positions in F1 are currently honorary, which necessitates that many officials, including Herbert, engage in other professional activities.
This dual role has been pinpointed as a source of conflict, especially when media involvement might influence or be perceived to influence race decisions.
The push for professional stewards has been gaining traction among F1 drivers and team principals. They argue for a dedicated, full-time team of officials to ensure consistent and unbiased rulings across races.
In an interview with Marca, Ben Sulayem addressed the situation directly. “Johnny was a very good steward, but then there was a conflict of interest and he knows that,” he said.
He further elaborated on the complexities of serving as both a journalist and a steward, questioning how one could remain unbiased: “You can’t be a journalist in a big company and express your point of view and then play the steward, who is a referee. You might say: ‘My best case scenario is that so-and-so wins.’ What if that driver you prefer has another driver in first or second place? How do you make your judgement?”
Ben Sulayem also noted that the exit was handled with mutual respect. “He understood [the reason for his exit] and he thanked the FIA [for the opportunity], and we thanked him for what he did,” he stated.
As Formula 1 gears up for the season opener, the 2025 Australian Grand Prix on March 16, the conversation around stewarding will be one to watch. This race at the Albert Park circuit will not only be a test of speed but also of the governance and oversight of the sport’s stewards.
