This Monday sees Brentford host Everton with Keith Andrews facing a major selection headache. Namely, the three-game ban of striker Igor Thiago.
The Brazilian will start his suspension following the red card in the 2-0 reverse at Brighton after catching Chema Andres in the face with his arm. The Brighton man going down with acting so hammy it made Rivaldo’s infamous pratfall look like Sir Patrick Stewart yet VAR eventually consigning Thiago to an early bath.
The Bees appealed but as we all knew beforehand, resistance was futile. The freeze frame shot of the incident, combined with the terrifying sight of, checks notes, some blood, ensured there would never be a reversal.
That’s before you get to the fact it would also have meant the disciplinary committee conceding that both Michael Oliver and Stuart Attwell had made a mistake. Frankly, there’s more chance of Cameron Diaz turning up at the Gtech then there is of it ever being admitted that the favourite sons had got it wrong.
So, Brentford go in to the game without their recognised front man. He’ll also be missing for the trip to Manchester United and the visit of Arsenal. That said, the slight positive being international break has afforded Keith an additional week to hone his tactics for this very scenario.
The obvious choice is to promote Callum Wilson from the bench to the starting XI, something the experienced striker is yet to do since joining the Bees over the summer.
He’s scored plenty of goals at this level and has shown all the energy and enthusiasm required when making his way on to the field. Whether, at 34 years old, he can still do it from the off rather than being the impact player is the big question Keith will have to consider.
The other option is play Kevin Schade through the middle. The German has been drifting more in to that position this season anyway, with Thiago as often forced out wide to retrieve then supply rather than sitting in the zone of scoreability himself.
Going this way would also have the benefit of leaving Keith no choice but to play Jaidon Anthony from the get go. Something he has seemed strangely reluctant to do despite the impression made every time he comes off the bench.
Personally, I’d go Wilson and stick with him for all three games. He’s the most natural in that role and has done it many, many times before.
Tell Schade to do his work out wide and leave the striking to the strikers. If a tactical rethink is needed, and we know how pragmatic Keith is when these are required, there’s always the option to switch Schade in at that point.
Perhaps as much as anything else, it is a conundrum to which the answer still revolves around ‘that’ game at Loftus Road back in March 2016. Dean Smith being forced in to a 4-6-0 formation with Alan Jugde operating as the so-called ‘false 9’.
It was a set up that met with the inevitable consequences of being forced to play without a conventional target man after both Lasse Vibe and Philipp Hofmann were missing through injury.
An awful afternoon where what happened off pitch was probably more entertaining. Whether BBC reporter Billy Reeves’ treating the touchline like his own, private discotheque or being ‘fly on the wall’ to a conversation taking place in the row directly behind me.
There, the emotion had clearly got to another fan who had been giving a running commentary down the phone to his, presumably, better half during the second half. As the Bees collapsed his call, which had been getting more and more aggravated, reached a sad denouement with the line, “Yes. I love you my darling. But we’re sh*t. Now please **** off”.
Language, Timothy. It was an afternoon that scarred us all in different ways although the collective feeling afterwards one of ‘never again’. Not even Dean Smith was able to say “We deserved to win” in his post-match press thingy. Whilst Keith has probably no idea whatsoever played out then – and why should he – it is a lesson he would do well to heed.
His other selection challenge is likely to come in the shape of Aaron Hickey. He was forced off with a hamstring injury on Monday evening as Scotland were trounced 4-0 in Switzerland (insert your own ‘more holes than a….’ joke here).
Yet with Keith very much favouring the player at present – whether as full back or unconventional midfielder – he’s likely to now have another enforced selection choice.
The obvious answer is to start Mathias Jensen and/or Mikkel Damsgaard. Vitaly Janelt is a complete shoe-in, and Yarmo impressed from the bench at Brighton. No mean feat given the all-round awfulness of that one. We’ve got the wonderful Mamadou Sangaré too so there’s no panic on that front.
To me, the set-up at Brighton felt beyond lopsided from the off. Jensen benched, and the Seagulls invited to come on to us, which they did by the bucketload. Four defenders became five with Hickey and KLP both covering the same spot and then playing three-quarters of the game with just ten men.
The outcome, inevitable. If anything, it could have been more than 2-0 with The Bees opting do nothing more than contain, even at 1-0, and Brighton guilty of over-elaborating.
Forget about it. We lost. We’re eighth. There are teams snapping at Brentford’s heels but all Keith can do now is box it off and pick his starting XI. For the record, I think he’ll go with:
Caoimhín Kelleher; Michael Kayode, Kris Ajer, Sepp van den Berg, Keane Lewis-Potter, Vitaly Janelt, Mathias Jensen, Mamadou Sangaré, Kevin Schade, Dango Ouattara, Jaidon Anthony.
That’s just my opinion, of course. Neither Keith or David Moyes are yet to speak with the press, so all we can do is speculate as to what either head coach will do.
Sixth-placed Everton come into this game on a high. They’re just two points off the Champions League slots and looking for a third successive win. Their performance at the Gtech last season in that hard fought 2-2 was as gutsy as our own tactical decision-making (substitutes, anybody?) was curious. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall’s 91st-minute equaliser as frustrating as it was predictable.
Now they have even bigger incentive to go for it again. With Jack Grealish the only likely of their higher-profile absentees, expect a starting XI of:
Jordan Pickford, Jake O’Brien, Former Brentford 26, Jarrad Branthwaite, Vitalii Mykolenko, Harrison Armstrong, James Garner, Merlin Röhl, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Tyrique George, Thierno Barry
Scary looking on paper. Formidable in practice. Even the pun potential they offer up is a headline writer’s dream. This one is going to be one of Keith’s toughest challenges for sure. Thankfully, we have a crack refereeing team of:
Referee: Craig Pawson.
Assistants: Nick Hopton, Adrian Holmes.
Fourth official: Paul Tierney.
VAR: Matt Donohue. Assistant VAR: Constantine Hatzidakis.
Anybody who was at Aston Villa will recall just what an incredible game Mr Pawson had , for all the wrong reasons. Finger’s crossed lightning won’t strike twice.
Until then, we’ve a wait until Monday night’s game. Perhaps it would be prudent to jinx your Fantasy Football team by picking man-of-the-moment Thierno Barry. Then put your feet up, enjoy the weekend action and, if Keith Andrews can outsmart David Moyes, get set for what would be the sweetest of victories.

